Is the author qualified to write about this topic? Adapted from: The University of the Fraser Valley 2009. Are there spelling, grammar or typographical errors? For further policy information and for a full list of regulatory specific contact persons visit the following webpage:. Whether you're buying a car, making medical decisions or casting your vote for a political candidate, you need to be able to discern fact from fiction, choose the most reliable data, and determine whether it's relevant to your needs. Navigation bar: this will help you answer questions about authority and purpose. A biased argument contains only one side of the argument, likely with little evidence to support claims. That breakthrough cancer treatment of five years ago might have already been deemed unsafe, and several new breakthrough treatments might now be in place. Before you decide whether you want to use the source in your essay, check to see if you can verify the information.
Internet Skills 1: How to Evaluate a Website. The site strongly criticizes drugs-and-surgery medicine, vaccines, corporate corruption, animal testing, the use of humans for medical experiments, the chemical contamination of foods, heavy metals in consumer products, factory farming and government corruption. The was developed by the Meriam Library at California State University, Chico to help you evaluate the information you find. You need to be able to evaluate and select the best material for use in your research and writing - both print sources and the information you find on the Internet. And while we believe conventional medicine has its place, we wholeheartedly endorse alternative, nutritional medicine because of our own personal experiences. Does the point of view appear objective and impartial? A — Authority: The source of the information.
If the subject were the not real endangered Pacific Northwest Pine Owl, would you be able to tell the site was a fake? Is the intended audience at an appropriate level? Does the website exist solely to sell you something? Different criteria will be more or less important depending on your situation or need. Hint: If the source deals with a controversial topic, look for an identification of the author's bias. Craap Showing top 8 worksheets in the category - Craap. Hint: Verify questionable facts, statistics, etc. It is a list of questions that help you determine if the sources you found are accurate and reliable. Don't depend on one source for all of your information, especially if you are not familiar with the topic.
I just wrote this to make a point. Test Showing top 8 worksheets in the category - Test. Is it to inform, teach, sell, entertain or persuade? Research and Education Institute: Information on King's papers and research about his work. Would you be comfortable citing this source in your research paper? Accuracy: The reliability, truthfulness and correctness of the content. Authority Who is the author? Does the information relate to your topic or answer your question? This is a good article to skip, too. Download a copy of the C. We do believe the basis for health is a balanced, nutrient rich, organic diet.
Have you looked at a variety of sources before determining this is the one you will use? Similarly, pay attention to which outside websites the site links to - if those outside websites don't provide good information or provide extremely biased information, that has bearing on the first website as well! Or, is the purpose to persuade? A lack of a navigation bar, or an unclear navigation bar, does not give the site much credibility. Purpose: The reason the information exists. If you're not sure how certain criteria apply to your information source, ask a librarian for help! Natural News covers holistic health, nutritional therapies, consciousness and spirituality, permaculture , organics, animal rights, environmental health, food and superfoods , and performance nutrition. Is the information supported by evidence? Is it trying to promote a political or religious agenda? This should include links to important information about the organization publishing the website, for example. Some of the worksheets displayed are Evaluating information applying the craap test, The craap test work, Ron lewis library thinking critically about web, Website evaluation and the craap test, Athletes instruction session 2 lesson plan, Western illinois university eng 180 section 11 ivy schedule, Workshop goals and objects, Teaching college students how to identify fake news. Is it to inform, teach, sell, entertain or persuade? Worksheet will open in a new window.
Does the author use to convince readers? Search results are selected by computer software, not by human experts. Again, this is especially important when evaluating websites. Websites that contain a lot of advertisements probably make a lot of their money from hosting advertisements; this means that their content may support, in part or in whole, the agenda of the companies and organizations advertising on their site. This video from the Chapman Learning Commons at the University of British Columbia provides a framework for assessing websites: C: Currency A: Authority P: Purpose O: Objectivity W: Writing Style Chapman Learning Commons. Keep in mind that this list is not static or complete.
Evaluation Criteria Currency: The timeliness of the information. Who is the intended audience? Does he or she work in the field? In this video, viewers will learn strategies for narrowing down results and honing in on credible sources. Next, read carefully to make sure the author uses ample evidence to support claims. Some of the worksheets displayed are Evaluating information applying the craap test, Preparing for the act 2018 2019, Test preparation work, Review basic mathematics math 010, Sample questions for students, Work for determining support, Civics history and government questions for the, Practice tabe lake city community college reading. Is it to inform, teach, sell, entertain or persuade? However, the site is very content-rich and well-organized. We do not diagnose or treat disease.
Relevance: The importance of the information for your needs. Is the information balanced, or is it? Has the author written other articles or books about the subject? P — Purpose: The reason the information exists. A five-year-old source may not be that old for some topics, but in the world of science and technology, five years might as well be a lifetime. Ask yourself who gains from advertisements, what the ads support, and who or what company is paying for a website's content. Citations and links will also help you evaluate the currency of the information on the website. What are the author's credentials or organizational affiliations? Advertisements: these will help you answer questions about purpose.