In this step, you have to decide to whom you should be loyal to. In other words, does he help the police by showing his unpublished photographs or does he support the right of journalists to protect their sources and their right to be impartial observers, free of government intervention? The account executive informs you that you have been assigned to the following new accounts which should bring in major revenue: Ku Klux Klan wants to recruit new members and the Rights to Life Society wants to promote a federal ban on abortions. For example, in journalism, the first allegiance is always to the public. The three products are first, tobacco products, which include cigarettes, chewing tobacco and snuff. By considering the values stated above from several ethical philosophies, the decision-maker is better equipped to understand the situation. But while choosing the principle, you should be sure that it is applicable to you situation. Photo images that appear in some newspapers in South America, for example, are often deemed too graphic for American eyes.
Best results; By honoring the company 2. Meanwhile, a lot of Internet users said they would have done the same thing if dealt with the same situation and called the charge unjust. When two different people analyze the same situation using the potter box, they can come to different conclusions. John Stuart Mill's Principle of Utility dictates that we must seek the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. The protesters had brought bolt cutters to breach the fence and gain access to the property, and when they began to cut the chain link the police threatened them with arrest and readied tear gas to disperse them. Why does the public need to know the unveiled truth of what was said? Basically, what do you stand for? It allows you to place the opposing points of view onto paper where they can be compared, which sometimes helps you to make the final decision. Health department test results 3.
By using the Potter Box, we are guided towards a decision after considering a number of elements and steps very carefully. The second quadrant is values. You bring photographs to the fire station after a big fire to curry favor at the next big fire. The fourth quadrant is loyalties Loyalties concern who the decision-maker has allegiances or loyalties to. This column appeared in the September 2011 issue of New Photographer Magazine. The decision maker starts with the Definition box. Stockholders that are planning on donating money to open a second restaurant are going to be in attendance.
How would other people describe the situation and why? Confucius' Golden Mean is more commonly known as the compromise principle and says moral virtue is the appropriate location between two extremes. The two situations they can define are either ignoring their knowledge of the bad food or canceling the event and risk losing an opportunity of receiving a grant for the second restaurant. I feel my sole purpose… 1936 Words 8 Pages exceeded our humanity. On March 14, the father and son were charged with murder over the death of a would-be robber as their act of self-defence is questionable from the aspects of law despite the strong supports from the Internet users from the aspects of emotion and sympathy. The Potter Box introduces four dimensions of moral In my opinion, the New York Times' decision to publish the article was of professional values, such as the public's right to know.
Aristotle teaches The Golden Mean, which encourages placing virtue between two extremes. At least it puts onto paper the conflict between the two views, and the process of thinking through the reasons and putting the conflict into words sometimes makes your decision easier. For journalists it may be truth, privacy, immediacy, or even an aesthetic value — which picture is most pleasing to the eye or is the ultimate decisive moment? For example, whistle blowing is one of those situations where you have determined that there is potential harm that could be done to society and therefore your loyalty to your employer needs to take second place to your loyalty to society. Therefore New York Times' decision to publish the article is also because of the values truth-telling and fairness. Aristotle's Golden Mean defines moral virtue as a middle state determined practical wisdom that emphasizes moderation and temperance.
Such variety suggests that the team of editors is most effective when diverse. Justice emerges when negotiating without social differentiations Agape Principle. In fact, the same person using the same issue could arrive at different decisions when using the box at two different times. Kevin Carter was highly criticized by the public for not helping the child in his famous famine and vulture photograph. Peter Southwick, Associate Professor of Journalism at Boston University faced one such incident in his earliest days as a newspaper photographer. No one can sort out their conflicting loyalties if they are deceiving themselves about what is at stake.
At some point in our careers, we have all probably witnessed behavior like this and possibly even acted that way ourselves in the face of intense pressure. Indeed, two different people analyzing the same issue with the Potter Box could arrive at two very different conclusions. Case Study 1 Part 1 Analyse the issue using the Potter Box. These help link concrete options to overarching principles, getting us to think about our own basic values. It was the photo of the man who chose to jump rather than die in the fire of the collapsing skyscraper. The definition stage of the Potter Box concerns the facts of the issue at hand.
The family who fought back was charged with murder over the death of the potential robber because the act of self-defence was questionable at the moment due to lack of evident. This decision might be made to protect unwanted attention to certain people. The steps go in a rotation to create a fluid process of decision-making. Mill teaches the Principle of Utility, which seeks the greatest good for the greatest number of people. Social justice is the predominant moral value. Are you loyal to yourself, the public, your readers or the law? What we would want others to do in this situation is considered. Ex: if you are loyal to the law, don't break it.